“Zinc or aluminium?” is the question we hear most often at the quoting stage, and the one most often answered badly. Two extremes are common: zinc is expensive, so use aluminium for everything; or zinc holds tighter tolerances, so use zinc for everything. Both end up costing more.
This guide breaks the decision into six criteria and gives an order to work through them — what to look at first, and what to talk about last.
Zinc ingot typically costs more than twice as much as aluminium per kilogram. That is where the “zinc is expensive” impression comes from — but it ignores density.
Zinc alloy density is about 6.6 g/cm³; aluminium about 2.7 g/cm³
For the same part volume, a zinc part weighs roughly 2.4 times as much
So the price gap per kilogram is amplified by weight, not reduced
The real difference lies elsewhere. Zinc melts at around 385 °C, aluminium at around 600 °C. Lower melting point means less melting energy, and zinc can run on hot-chamber machines — melting pot and injection integrated, shorter cycle, higher output. Zinc is also gentler on tooling, so die life is significantly longer.
| Criterion | Zinc alloy | Aluminium alloy |
|---|---|---|
| Material and part cost | Higher unit price, higher density; often cheaper for small parts | Lower unit price; better for large parts |
| Dimensional accuracy | Low shrinkage, tighter tolerances and thinner walls | Higher shrinkage, thin walls harder to control |
| Strength and heat | Moderate strength; not ideal for sustained heat | High strength and heat resistance |
| Surface finishing | Best for plating (Ni/Cr) and polishing | Anodising, powder coating, passivation |
| Corrosion | Stable indoors | Needs coating or anodising outdoors |
| Volume and tooling | Hot chamber, short cycle, long die life | Cold chamber, longer cycle, higher tooling cost |
Zinc shrinks about 0.4–0.6% and flows well, so it fills thin sections more reliably. Three practical consequences:
Very thin walls (thin housings, decorative plates) are easier to hold in zinc
Small precision parts that must be close to final size as-cast favour zinc
Parts that will be plated or polished benefit from a zinc substrate
Aluminium shrinks about 0.6–1.0% with a wider solidification range, so thin walls and fine features are harder to keep consistent. Precision aluminium parts often need CNC afterwards — which adds cost.
Aluminium has a much better strength-to-weight ratio and handles heat better, so structural, load-bearing and heat-adjacent parts almost always use aluminium.
Automotive safety parts (steering, actuators, chassis supports) — strength and fatigue life
Thermal parts — aluminium conducts heat far better than zinc
Outdoor structural parts — anodising provides durable protection
Zinc loses strength faster under sustained heat, so it is not the right choice near engines or lamp heat sources.
| Finish | Zinc | Aluminium |
|---|---|---|
| Plating (Ni/Cr) | First choice, excellent adhesion and brightness | Needs special pre-treatment, higher cost |
| Polishing | Excellent, ideal for decorative parts | Softer, scratches easily |
| Anodising | Not applicable | First choice, colour and hard anodising |
| Powder coating | Possible | Common |
Appliance knobs, decorative rings and hinges — parts that are seen and must look bright — are almost always zinc. Parts needing matte, coloured or wear-resistant surfaces are aluminium with anodising.
| Application | Usual choice | Typical parts |
|---|---|---|
| Appliance drive and trim | Zinc | Door shafts, latches, selector rings |
| Automotive structure and safety | Aluminium | Steering components, actuator housings, sunroof parts |
| Electronics thermal and structure | Aluminium | CPO heat sink brackets, HDD brackets, motor brackets |
| Energy and fluid control | Mostly aluminium | Gas regulators, gas valve bodies |
| Enclosures and industrial hardware | Zinc | Cabinet handles |
On our own lines: household appliance castings are mostly zinc, automotive castings mostly aluminium, alongside electronics castings and energy management castings.
Zinc examples: door shaft, washing machine selector ring, cabinet handle — small, light, appearance-critical.
For thin-wall capability in aluminium, actuator housing is a good example: wall thickness control is the hard part.
Many parts can be made in either. Work through these four questions in order:
Annual volume? At low volumes tooling amortisation dominates, and zinc's hot-chamber process and long die life help more
How tight is the tolerance? If it must be near-final as-cast, lean zinc
Any cosmetic requirement? High-bright plating points to zinc; colour and matte point to aluminium
What is the service environment? Heat, outdoors or load-bearing favour aluminium
If all four point the same way, the decision is clear. If they conflict — high precision plus high strength, for example — the usual solution is an aluminium body with machining allowance on the critical interfaces.
Always include downstream operations. Plating and polishing for zinc, anodising and powder coating for aluminium differ a lot in unit cost and yield. And when an aluminium part needs machining at several locations, the machining hours usually cost more than the material difference.
In short: compare the complete cost from blank to finished part, not the material price per kilogram.
We run both zinc and aluminium lines and can recommend a material and give a cost estimate before tooling is cut. If you are stuck on a drawing, send the critical dimensions and service conditions and we will give you a comparison.